Skip to content

Free Shipping on Standard but Not Express on Shopify

How to keep a Shopify free shipping discount off your express rate using the rate exclusion setting, with a worked example and the three ways it breaks.

How-to guidesThe diex team10 min read

You launch a free shipping promotion, announce it, and then watch an order come through where the customer took next-day express and paid nothing for it. Shopify's free shipping discount does not know the difference between your standard rate and your express rate. There is exactly one native setting for this, and it works well in some rate tables and not at all in others. Here is how to pick its value from your own rates, and when to stop trying.

Why a free shipping discount makes every rate free

Shopify sorts discounts into three classes. Product discounts apply to specific items or collections, order discounts apply to cart subtotals, and shipping discounts modify shipping costs, according to Shopify's documentation on discount combinations. A free shipping discount is a shipping discount, and what it modifies is whatever shipping rate the customer picked at checkout.

That is the whole problem. Your rates live in Settings, in a shipping profile, with names you wrote. Your discount lives in Discounts. The discount form has no field that references a rate name. So when a customer selects Express Shipping at $18.50 and applies your code, Shopify removes $18.50.

You also cannot fix it by layering a second discount on top. The same page states that multiple shipping discounts cannot apply to the same order, and that a customer can apply up to five product or order discount codes plus one shipping discount code per order. There is no "free standard" discount that a separate "express is still paid" rule can override.

The one native lever: exclude shipping rates over an amount

On the free shipping discount form, under the countries section, there is a checkbox: Exclude shipping rates over a certain amount. Check it and type an amount. Shopify's help page on free shipping discounts is explicit that this applies to shipping rates only and is unrelated to the order amount, which is the separate minimum purchase requirement.

So the discount covers rates priced at or below your number and leaves anything above it alone. You are not naming a method. You are drawing a price line between your methods and hoping your methods stay on their side of it.

Note the word "over". A rate priced exactly at the amount you type is not over it, so it still gets discounted. If you type $18.50 and your express rate is $18.50, express goes free. Shopify's help center does not spell out this boundary, but Shopify Support has answered it directly in a community thread on keeping free shipping off expedited rates: "Remember to set the exclusion amount lower than the expedited shipping rate as the same amount will still make the expedited shipping rate eligible for the discount." That is a support reply rather than documentation, so confirm the behavior yourself in a test checkout before you rely on it.

Pick the exclusion amount from your own rate table

Go to Settings > Shipping and delivery and open each shipping profile. For every zone, write down the rate Name (which is what customers see at checkout) and the Price. Shopify's guide to setting up shipping rates covers the four rate types you will find there: Flat, Order amount, Weight, and Carrier or app calculated.

For example, say your domestic zone looks like this:

Rate name Rate type Customer pays
Standard (3 to 5 days) Flat $6.95
Express (1 to 2 days) Flat $18.50
Overnight Flat $32.00

The highest rate you want to cover is $6.95. The cheapest rate you want to keep charging for is $18.50. Your usable range is anything from $6.95 up to $18.49, and the sensible choice is near the middle: $12. Standard is not over $12, so it goes free. Express and Overnight are over $12, so they stay at full price.

Two rules make this hold up:

  • Leave headroom on both sides. Picking $6.95 works today but breaks the moment your standard rate rises by a dime. Picking $18.49 breaks if you ever trim express to $17.99.
  • Count every rate, not every method. A weight-based standard rate priced at $6.95 up to 5 lb, $12.95 to 20 lb, and $24.00 above that is three rates, not one. A $12 threshold would make light carts free and charge heavy carts the full $24, under the same rate name. Customers will notice.

If the gap between your cheapest express rate and your most expensive standard rate is less than a couple of dollars, this lever is not reliable. Skip to the last two sections.

Set it up step by step

For a discount code:

  1. In your admin, go to Discounts and click Create discount, then Free shipping.
  2. Select Discount code and enter a code or generate one.
  3. Under countries, leave All countries or choose Selected countries.
  4. Check Exclude shipping rates over a certain amount and enter the amount from your rate table.
  5. Add a Minimum purchase amount or Minimum quantity of items if your offer has one. Shopify's free shipping page notes that the minimum purchase amount counts product prices and never includes taxes, and that all products in the cart count toward it, including gift cards.
  6. Set eligibility, then usage limits (a total number of uses, one use per customer, or both).
  7. Under Combinations, check which product and order discount classes may combine with it. Product plus shipping and order plus shipping are both allowed; shipping plus shipping is not. Our guide to what actually stacks in Shopify discount combinations goes through the rest of the matrix.
  8. Set active dates and save.

For an automatic discount, follow the same path but select Automatic discount and enter a customer-facing title instead of a code. Keep the ceiling in mind: Shopify's combinations page puts the limit at 25 active automatic discounts per store, including app-based discounts.

Where the exclusion breaks

Carrier-calculated rates move under you

With carrier accounts connected, Shopify pulls live rates based on order weight, dimensions, and destination, as described in Shopify's page on third-party carrier-calculated shipping. That page also sets the plan boundary: third-party carrier-calculated shipping is available on Shopify Advanced and Shopify Plus, and Grow stores can get it for an additional monthly fee or by switching to annual billing.

The consequence for this trick is simple. The number at checkout is not a number you typed. A ground service can quote $7.20 on a one-pound order and $19.40 on a twelve-pound order to a distant zone. A $12 threshold frees one and not the other, and nothing in your admin warns you. Handling fees, which you can add as a percentage or flat amount on the rate, push the quote further around.

If you want a dependable free shipping promotion, swap the promotional service to a flat rate or an order-amount rate for the duration, so the price is yours and not the carrier's.

Rates that sit close together

Standard at $8.95 and express at $10.95 leaves you a window of $8.95 to $10.94. One seasonal surcharge, one handling fee change, one rounding difference on an international quote, and either express goes free or standard stops being free. A two-dollar gap is not a configuration, it is a coin flip.

Rate tables that differ per market

The exclusion amount is one number for the whole discount, but your zones have different prices. Say domestic standard is $6.95 and your UK standard is $14. A $12 threshold frees domestic standard and leaves UK customers paying in full, which is probably not what your email said.

The fix is one discount per country group, each using Selected countries with its own exclusion amount. That is workable for automatic discounts and for separate codes per region, and awkward if you promised one code to everyone. Our guide on limiting a Shopify discount to one country or market walks through the targeting options.

Currency adds a second wrinkle. Shopify's documentation on discounts in international markets states that fixed-amount discounts are set in the currency of your store, that the amount is converted to the customer's currency at checkout, and that the converted amount can fluctuate with exchange rates. Treat any threshold you set as approximate for buyers outside your home currency, and see what customers actually get from discounts in multiple currencies.

One more thing worth knowing if your rate screens look unfamiliar: Shopify is rolling out shipping options by market, described as a delivery choice a customer can select at checkout such as Standard or Express, with only the single highest matching rate applying when several rates in an option match the cart. That page says the feature is in early access and available only to certain stores. It changes where you read your rates. It does not give the discount form a way to name one.

What to do when you need to target a rate by name

Three honest options, cheapest first.

  1. Widen the price gap. Move standard down or express up until the two are far apart, then set the threshold in the middle. This costs you nothing but a pricing decision and it makes the native setting trustworthy.
  2. Remove the premium rate for the promo window. Blunt, immediate, and it costs you whatever express revenue you would have earned.
  3. Use a shipping discount function. Shopify's Discount Function API includes a cart.delivery-options.discounts.generate.run target, and a delivery option target takes a handle, documented as a unique, human-readable identifier of the delivery option's title. That is rate-by-name targeting, and it survives price changes because it never looks at the price. Mind the plan rules: functions inside a public App Store app work on any Shopify plan, but Shopify's Functions documentation states that only stores on a Shopify Plus plan can use custom apps containing Function APIs. On any other plan, this route means finding a public app that does shipping rate rules rather than hiring a developer to build one for your store. Either way it is still a shipping discount, so it still cannot combine with another shipping discount.

Said plainly: if your standard and express prices are close together, carrier-quoted, or very different by destination, the native checkbox cannot do this job. Do not build a campaign on it and hope.

Test it in a real checkout before you announce it

  1. Create the discount with a future start date, or create it and keep the announcement in draft.
  2. Build a cart close to a typical order and go to checkout. Shopify's managing discounts page covers editing and deactivating if the test goes badly.
  3. Apply the code and read the shipping step line by line. Standard should show as free. Express and overnight should show their full prices.
  4. Repeat with your lightest realistic cart, your heaviest, and a cart that just clears the minimum purchase amount.
  5. Repeat with a shipping address in every zone the promotion covers.
  6. If you also run a free shipping rate above an order threshold, test the code alongside a product discount. A product discount reduces the subtotal and can drop the cart under that threshold, which is covered in why discount codes break your free shipping threshold.

Do this week

  • Open Settings > Shipping and delivery and write out every rate name, type and price, zone by zone. Most merchants have more rates than they remember.
  • Measure the gap between your most expensive qualifying rate and your cheapest premium rate. Under two dollars means restructure the rates before you promote anything.
  • If any qualifying rate is carrier-calculated, add a flat rate for the promotion window so the price stops moving.
  • Create the discount with the exclusion amount in the middle of the gap, then run the checkout tests above in every zone you are promoting to.
  • Leave a comment on the discount's timeline recording the exclusion amount and the rate prices it depends on, so the next person who edits a shipping rate knows a promotion is tied to it. Timeline comments are visible only to you and your staff.

Sources

  1. Shopify Help Center: Free shipping discounts
  2. Shopify Help Center: Discount combinations
  3. Shopify Help Center: Setting up shipping zones and rates
  4. Shopify Help Center: Third-party carrier-calculated shipping
  5. Shopify Help Center: Discounts in international markets
  6. Shopify Help Center: Shipping options by market
  7. Shopify Help Center: Managing discounts
  8. Shopify.dev: Discount Function API
  9. Shopify.dev: Shopify Functions
  10. Shopify Community (Shopify Support reply): Free shipping promotion on standard shipping only

Drafted with AI from the sources above and checked automatically against them and our product facts. Spotted a mistake? Email help@diex.app.

More articles

Run the promotions you actually want to run

Install diex from the Shopify App Store. One plan at $29.99 a month, billed by Shopify.