Skip to content

Amount Off Products or Amount Off Order? How to Choose

Shopify's two amount off discount types differ in scope, minimums and per-order limits. A decision table plus margin math on the same $120 cart.

How-to guidesThe diex team10 min read

You are on Shopify's create-discount screen. The first menu offers Amount off products and Amount off orders, and nothing on that screen tells you which one your promotion needs. The two look interchangeable for a simple "25% off" sale, and they are not. The choice changes which items get cheaper, what a minimum purchase requirement measures, and how much gross profit you hand over on a mixed cart. Here is how to decide, with the same $120 cart priced both ways.

The two options, in Shopify's own words

Both types live on one page in Shopify's documentation, amount off products and amount off order discounts, and the setup flows are nearly identical. One field separates them.

An amount off products discount has an Applies to section. Shopify's steps say: "To apply a discount to specific products, select Specific products, and then add your products. To apply a discount to specific collections, select Specific collections, and then add your collections." That step is marked optional, so if you skip it the discount reaches across your catalog.

An amount off orders discount has no Applies to selector. There is nothing to scope. It reduces the order.

They also sit in different discount classes, which matters when more than one discount is in play. Shopify's discount combinations documentation sets the sequence: "Product discounts apply first to individual items. Order discounts apply to the revised subtotal after product discounts. Shipping discounts apply last." A customer can use a maximum of five product or order discount codes plus one shipping discount code on the same order. If you already have a permanent order-level offer running, a product discount is the one that can sit beside it in a different class. We go deeper on that in what actually stacks.

Scope: what each discount touches in a mixed cart

Real carts are mixed. Someone comes in for the clearance item, adds a new arrival, and checks out with both.

An order discount is blind to that. It sees a subtotal. A 25% off order code on a cart holding one clearance candle and one full-price diffuser takes 25% off the candle and 25% off the diffuser, because there is no mechanism in the discount to distinguish them.

A product discount sees line items. Scope it to your Clearance collection and the diffuser stays at full price. The customer still gets the offer they came for, and you keep the margin on the item they were going to buy anyway.

This is the part merchants learn from a sales report rather than from the setup screen. The discount worked exactly as configured. It just also applied to revenue that needed no help.

One caveat on the mirror image: an amount off products discount with the Applies to step skipped covers everything, so it looks like an order discount. It is not one. It stays in the product class, and its minimum purchase requirement behaves differently, which is the next section.

The same $120 cart, priced both ways

For example, say you sell home fragrance and want to move candles. Three items in the cart:

Item Price Unit cost In the Candles collection
Large candle $40.00 $14.00 Yes
Candle refill $30.00 $10.50 Yes
Reed diffuser $50.00 $22.00 No
Total $120.00 $46.50

At full price that cart earns $73.50 of gross profit, a 61.3% margin. Now run 25% off two ways.

Full price 25% off, amount off products (Candles) 25% off, amount off orders
Discount taken $0.00 $17.50 $30.00
Revenue $120.00 $102.50 $90.00
Cost of goods $46.50 $46.50 $46.50
Gross profit $73.50 $56.00 $43.50
Gross margin 61.3% 54.6% 48.3%

Same headline offer, same cart, $12.50 difference. That $12.50 is exactly 25% of the diffuser, an item that was not part of the promotion. It is 17% of the gross profit the cart would have produced at full price, spent on nothing you asked for.

Scale that across a month of mixed carts and it stops being a rounding error. The honest version of the trade-off: the order discount is simpler to explain in an email and applies to everyone's cart, which is the point if your goal is a sitewide event. The product discount costs less per order because it refuses to discount what it was not aimed at.

What counts toward the minimum purchase amount

This is the second consequence, and the two types measure completely different things.

For a product discount, Shopify is explicit: "Only the selected products, or products in selected collections, count towards the minimum purchase amount for an amount off product discount." So "spend $100, get 25% off candles" with a $100 minimum means $100 of candles. A cart with $60 of candles and $80 of diffusers does not qualify, even though the subtotal is $140. Customers read that as a broken code.

For an order discount, Shopify checks the threshold twice. Both of the following must meet the minimum: "Before product discounts: The total for the selected purchase type, excluding purchased gift cards" and "After product discounts: The cart subtotal, including all purchase types and including purchased gift cards."

The second check is the one that surprises people. If another product discount is already combining on that cart and pulls the subtotal under your threshold, the order discount stops applying. A $100 minimum order discount plus a stacking 20% off product discount on a $110 cart leaves an $88 subtotal, and the order discount drops out. Nothing is misconfigured. Your "spend $100, save $15" offer simply fails at the moment the customer is most likely to leave, and checkout is already fragile: Baymard Institute puts the average documented cart abandonment rate at 70.22%, the unweighted average of 50 studies published between 2006 and 2025.

Rules that apply to both types, per the same help page:

  • The minimum counts product prices only. Shipping costs and taxes are not included.
  • Purchased gift cards do not count toward the minimum for a product discount unless you specifically select the gift card product.
  • Gift cards and store credit used as payment do not affect the minimum purchase amount.
  • For automatic discounts, Shopify's steps have you set a minimum purchase amount or minimum quantity of items. That step is not marked optional, unlike the equivalent step in the discount code flow.

If you are building thresholds, our longer piece on what counts toward a Shopify minimum purchase amount walks the edge cases.

"Only apply discount once per order" and other per-order limits

There is a checkbox that exists only on the product side of this fork, and only for fixed amounts. Shopify's instructions: "If you're creating a fixed amount automatic discount that can be applied to specific products or collections, then you can check Only apply discount once per order to limit the number of times the discount applies."

Leave it unchecked and the amount applies to each eligible item. Shopify's Admin API documents the same switch on the appliesOnEachItem field: "If true, then the discount is applied to each of the entitled items. If false, then the amount is split across all of the entitled items."

So, continuing the example: a $20 off discount scoped to the Candles collection, left unchecked, on a cart holding three $40 candles, takes $60 off a $120 cart. That is half off, from a $20 coupon. Check the box and $20 comes off once, split across the candle lines.

An order discount has no such setting, because the order is counted once by definition. A $20 off order code takes $20.

Percentage values do not get this checkbox at all, which is a quiet argument for percentages when you are scoping to products: a percentage scales with the cart on purpose, and there is no hidden multiplier. We compare the two value types in percentage or fixed amount.

A decision table: pick by what you are trying to protect

What you are trying to do Pick Why
Discount a category without touching full-price items Amount off products Applies to scopes it to products or collections
Clear one collection or a short end-of-line list Amount off products The discount cannot leak onto new arrivals
Lift average order value with "spend $X, save $Y" Amount off orders The threshold measures the whole cart
Make the threshold measure only the promo items Amount off products Only selected products count toward the minimum
Make the threshold measure everything in the cart Amount off orders Checked before and after product discounts
Take a fixed dollar amount off once, cart-wide Amount off orders No per-item multiplication to reason about
Run alongside an existing order-level offer Amount off products Different discount class, so it can combine
Sitewide event where every cart should drop Amount off orders Simplest to communicate and to audit

Two jobs sit outside both native options. If you need a different value on each product under a single code, that is not something either type does: an amount off products discount carries one value for everything it covers. And if you want the discount to grow as the order total grows, Shopify's order discount has a single threshold, not a ladder. Both are what diex does, with variable discounts for a different amount per product or variant under one code, and spend tiers for a bigger discount as the order total crosses each threshold. Everything in the decision table above, Shopify's built-in discounts handle on their own.

Set it up and confirm the right items got discounted

From Shopify admin:

  1. Go to Discounts and click Create discount.
  2. From the Select discount type menu, click Amount off products or Amount off orders.
  3. Under Method, select Discount code or Automatic discount.
  4. Enter the code or the title, then set the value as a percentage or a fixed amount.
  5. For a product discount, use Applies to to select Specific products or Specific collections. Confirm the collection actually contains what you think it does before saving.
  6. For a fixed-amount product discount, decide on Only apply discount once per order deliberately. Do not leave it at the default without reading the previous section.
  7. Set Minimum requirements, remembering that a product discount counts only the selected items and an order discount is checked before and after product discounts.
  8. Set Eligibility, Combinations and Active dates, then click Save.

Then test it before the email goes out. Build a deliberately mixed cart on your storefront: one item inside the promotion, one clearly outside it, and more than one unit of the promoted item. Apply the code and compare the discount shown to the number you expected. If a $20 fixed amount takes $40 or $60, the once-per-order checkbox is the cause. If the code refuses to apply, check the minimum against what that discount type actually counts.

After a real order lands, open it under Orders. Shopify notes that "the subtotal displayed in your Shopify admin excludes discounts. Discounts are displayed as a separate line item," so you can read the discount amount off the order and check it against the cart you expected.

What to do this week

  • Take your next planned promotion and write down one sentence: which items should get cheaper, and which should not. That sentence picks the type for you.
  • Open your live discounts and find any amount off orders discount that was meant to target a category. Rebuild it as an amount off products discount scoped to that collection.
  • Check every fixed-amount product discount for the Only apply discount once per order setting, then test one with three units in the cart.
  • Run the $120-cart math on your own best-selling mixed basket at your real costs. If the gap between the two types is more than a few percent of margin, scope matters more to you than simplicity.

Sources

  1. Shopify Help Center: Amount off products and amount off order discounts
  2. Shopify Help Center: Discount combinations
  3. Shopify Admin GraphQL API: DiscountAmountInput
  4. Shopify Help Center: Managing order details
  5. Baymard Institute: 50 cart abandonment rate statistics

Drafted with AI from the sources above and checked automatically against them and our product facts. Spotted a mistake? Email help@diex.app.

More articles

Run the promotions you actually want to run

Install diex from the Shopify App Store. One plan at $29.99 a month, billed by Shopify.