Skip to content

Percentage or Fixed Amount? Choosing a Shopify Discount Type

How Shopify applies percentage and fixed amount discounts, what each one costs your margin, and which to pick for low and high priced carts.

Discount strategyThe diex team10 min read

Shopify's discount editor gives you two options for value, Percentage and Fixed amount, and no guidance on which to pick. The choice changes three separate things: what the discount costs you per order, how big the saving looks to the shopper, and how Shopify spreads the value across the items in the cart. That third one is where merchants get burned, because a fixed amount off products behaves nothing like a fixed amount off the order. Here is what each type actually does, and how to decide.

What actually changes when you switch from Percentage to Fixed amount

A percentage is a ratio. Its cost moves with the price of whatever is in the cart, so 15% off is 15% off whether the order is $30 or $300.

A fixed amount is a number of currency units. Its cost stays the same in dollars no matter what the cart is worth, which means its cost as a percentage moves instead, and moves in the direction you usually do not want: biggest on the smallest orders.

Both options are available on the two main amount off discounts, Amount off products and Amount off order, and both can be a discount code or an automatic discount. Neither touches delivery. Shopify's amount off discounts documentation states that these discounts "don't apply to shipping costs." If you want to give away shipping, that is a separate free shipping discount, where you can leave All countries selected or pick specific countries, and optionally check "Exclude shipping rates over a certain amount" so an express rate does not come along for free.

How Shopify applies each type: per item, once per order, and split lines

This is the part that costs real money, and it is worth ten minutes of your attention before you launch anything.

Fixed amount off products applies to every eligible item

On an Amount off products discount, the value lands on each product that qualifies. Shopify's documentation includes an optional step for exactly this case: "To create a fixed value discount code that can be applied to specific products or collections, check Only apply discount once per order to limit the customer to using the code only one time per order." Leave it unchecked and, in Shopify's words, "the discount applies to all eligible products in the order."

For example, say you set up $10 off a collection of 40 candles and a customer buys four of them. Unchecked, that is $40 off, not $10. If your intent was "$10 off this order," you wanted either the checkbox or an Amount off order discount instead.

Percentages do not have this trap in the same way, because a percentage applied to four items is still the same rate on those four items. The number scales with what the shopper bought, which is what most people assume a discount does.

A fixed amount spread over several items gets divided between the lines

When a fixed amount has to cover more than one item, Shopify divides the value across them. Its own worked example on the amount off discounts page reads: "if you have a $50 USD discount applied to a cart with a $50 USD item and a $100 USD item, then the first item is discounted by $16.50 USD and the second one by $33.50 USD."

Read those numbers carefully. The split roughly tracks the prices, but it is not a clean one third and two thirds, which would be $16.67 and $33.33. Shopify's documentation gives this outcome without stating the rule behind it, so treat the per line allocation as something Shopify decides, not something you can predict to the cent. It matters in three places: partial refunds (the refund amount follows the discounted line, not the sticker price), per SKU margin reporting, and anything downstream that reads line level discounts. A percentage never has this problem, because each line gets the same rate and the arithmetic is obvious.

One more mechanic on Amount off order discounts: if you add a minimum purchase amount, Shopify checks it twice, against the total before product discounts and the total after product discounts. A product discount that has already fired can therefore push a cart under your order discount minimum.

What the research says about which number feels bigger

The common advice is the rule of 100: use percentages below $100 and dollar amounts above it. Jonah Berger, who popularized it, puts it as "under 100 percentage discounts seem larger than absolute ones. But over 100, things reverse" (Berger on the rule of 100). The research behind that framing holds up reasonably well.

Chen, Monroe and Lou tested price reductions framed in percentage versus dollar terms on high and low price products. In their words: "For the high-price product, our subjects indicated that a price reduction framed in dollar terms seemed more significant than the same price reduction framed in percentage terms, and the opposite was true for the low-price product" (Journal of Retailing, 1998, abstract). Percentage framing reads bigger on cheap things. Dollar framing reads bigger on expensive things.

The practical translation: on a $20 product, "25% off" lands harder than the identical "$5 off." On a $400 product, "$100 off" lands harder than the identical "25% off." Pick the frame that makes the same discount sound like more.

Two honest caveats. This is a 1998 study measuring perceptions and stated purchase intentions in a controlled setting, not conversion in your store, and your catalog is not their stimulus set. Treat it as a sensible default for how to present a saving, then confirm it against your own numbers. The same paper also found that "coupon promotions were evaluated more favorably and were more effective in changing subjects' purchase intentions" than equivalent discount promotions, though a 1998 coupon is a clipped piece of paper rather than a code typed at checkout, so do not read that as a straight verdict on automatic discounts versus discount codes.

The margin difference: a capped cost versus a cost that grows with the cart

Framing decides what the offer sounds like. Mechanics decide what it costs. Here is the same promotion run both ways across four cart sizes, as an illustration with made up numbers:

Cart subtotal 20% off $15 off 20% off, as % $15 off, as %
$25 $5.00 $15.00 20% 60%
$60 $12.00 $15.00 20% 25%
$150 $30.00 $15.00 20% 10%
$400 $80.00 $15.00 20% 3.8%

Two different risk profiles fall out of that table.

A fixed amount caps your worst case in dollars. You will never give away more than $15 per order, which makes budgeting a campaign straightforward. But its cost as a share of revenue has no ceiling: the smaller the cart, the higher the effective rate. On a $25 cart you handed over 60% of the subtotal, almost certainly more than your gross margin on that order. Fixed amount discounts fail on small carts.

A percentage holds the rate constant, so if your gross margin is reasonably uniform you know the discount can never exceed your margin. But its cost in dollars has no ceiling either: one $2,000 order quietly costs you $400. Percentage discounts fail on unusually large carts.

The fix for fixed amount is a minimum purchase requirement set well above the discount value, so the effective rate can never run away. The fix for percentage is a shallower rate, or excluding your highest ticket products from the discount. Either way, work out your floor first: our guide on how deep a discount can go before it costs you money walks the gross margin math. And remember that both types reduce the subtotal, which can drop a cart under a free shipping threshold the shopper had already cleared.

When fixed amount is the safer choice

  • Your average item price is high, so a dollar figure sounds bigger than the equivalent percentage.
  • You need a hard ceiling on cost per order, for example a campaign with a fixed budget.
  • The offer is built around a round number the shopper can picture: "$20 off orders over $100."
  • You are clearing specific products at a known price, where the dollar off and the final price are both obvious.
  • You are running a thank you or make good credit, where a flat value is the point.

Always pair it with a minimum purchase amount, and if it is an Amount off products discount, decide deliberately whether "Only apply discount once per order" should be checked.

When percentage is the safer choice

  • Your catalog spans a wide price range, which is most stores.
  • Your items are low ticket, where the research says a percentage reads larger.
  • Cart size varies a lot and you cannot predict it, so you want cost to scale with the order.
  • Your gross margin is roughly consistent as a percentage across products, so one rate is safe everywhere.
  • The discount sits on quantity or spend tiers and you want each tier to stay proportionate.

Percentages have no natural ceiling, so set the rate against your thinnest margin product in scope, not your average.

Mixed-price catalogs: why one value across everything backfires

A single fixed amount across a mixed catalog produces nonsense at both ends. For example, say you run $10 off a catalog that spans a $19 accessory and a $220 jacket. That is 53% off the accessory, which is probably below cost, and 4.5% off the jacket, which no shopper will notice. One value cannot be right for both.

You have three ways out. Switch to a percentage, which self adjusts. Split the campaign into separate discounts per collection, each with its own value, and check how they combine so they do not stack unintentionally. Or set a different value per product.

That last option is what variable discounts in diex do: one code or automatic discount carrying a different value off each product or variant. The whole discount is either percentages or fixed amounts (that is one setting), so you cannot mix 30% off one product with $5 off another inside a single discount, which takes two. The same one setting rule applies to volume discounts and spend tiers, where each tier gets its own value but the type is chosen once for the discount. If your catalog is tight enough that one value works everywhere, Shopify's built in discounts already do the job and you do not need anything else.

Check it in a test cart this week

  1. Open your live or planned discount and write down, in one sentence, what you intend it to cost on a typical order. If you cannot state that number, stop and work it out.
  2. If it is a fixed amount on specific products or collections, look at whether "Only apply discount once per order" matches that sentence.
  3. Add one eligible item to a test cart on your storefront, then three of the same item, then a mixed cart with a cheap and an expensive product. Read the discount line in the cart and again at checkout. Three carts, five minutes.
  4. Divide the discount shown by the subtotal for each of those carts. If any effective rate exceeds your gross margin, add or raise the minimum purchase amount.
  5. Check the largest of those carts still clears your free shipping threshold after the discount comes off.
  6. Reread the offer copy with the research in mind: percentage on your cheap products, dollars on your expensive ones, for the identical saving.

Sources

  1. Shopify Help Center: Amount off products and amount off order discounts
  2. Shopify Help Center: Free shipping discounts
  3. Chen, Monroe & Lou (1998), The effects of framing price promotion messages on consumers' perceptions and purchase intentions, Journal of Retailing (abstract)
  4. Jonah Berger: Fuzzy Math: What Makes Something Seem Like A Good Deal?

Drafted with AI from the sources above and checked automatically against them and our product facts. Spotted a mistake? Email help@diex.app.

More articles

Run the promotions you actually want to run

Install diex from the Shopify App Store. One plan at $29.99 a month, billed by Shopify.